—
Are Americans financially worse off under President Donald Trump than they were under former President Joe Biden? Republican Sen. Rand Paul recently suggested they are, citing inflation, federal debt, and shrinking purchasing power. His criticism is especially notable coming from a member of Trump’s own party. For households trying to make the right moves, the question goes beyond politics to what their paychecks can actually afford.
Paul’s comments arrive as the Trump administration argues it has made progress controlling inflation after inheriting what the president characterized as an economic catastrophe. Competing claims about affordability are putting both administrations’ economic records under scrutiny.
Here’s what you need to know.
Rand Paul says inflation has left Americans poorer
In a late-September post on X, Sen. Paul warned that federal debt had surpassed $40 trillion, which he described as more than $360,000 per American taxpayer. He acknowledged that deficits were running below Biden-era levels but argued that Americans’ purchasing power remained substantially weaker.
Paul also maintained that someone earning $50,000 annually is poorer than a few years ago because inflation compounds over time. His central point was that even when inflation slows, households don’t automatically regain the purchasing power they’ve already lost.
The $40 trillion figure refers to accumulated national debt, not the annual deficit. The federal deficit for fiscal 2026 was approximately $2 trillion.
Trump argues his administration inherited the problem
Trump has repeatedly argued that his administration inherited an inflation crisis from Biden. During his March 2025 address to Congress, he described the economy he inherited as an “economic catastrophe” marked by an “inflation nightmare.” The administration has promoted tax changes, deregulation, and domestic energy production as measures intended to improve affordability.
Paul’s criticism challenges that interpretation by emphasizing accumulated price increases rather than individual policy achievements. Still, determining which president left Americans financially better off requires comparing prices, earnings, assets, and living costs over consistent periods.
Inflation peaked under Biden, but prices kept rising
The largest inflation surge of the past several years occurred during Biden’s presidency. According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, annual consumer price inflation reached 9.1% in June 2022, its highest level in approximately four decades.
Inflation subsequently cooled, but that didn’t mean prices returned to their earlier levels. This has left households facing substantially higher expenses than they did several years earlier.
Inflation has also accelerated during Trump’s second term. The latest BLS report shows consumer prices rose 3.7% over the 12 months ending September 2026, including a particularly sharp increase in gasoline prices. That explains why both administrations can be associated with significant inflation pressures, although the timing and scale differ.
Gas prices are up significantly
Gasoline provides another example of how comparisons can change depending on the period examined.
For example, AAA data showed the national average reached approximately $4.48 per gallon as of late September 2026. The conflict with Iran has disrupted energy markets and has pushed prices substantially higher since the onset of the war in early 2026. So someone filling their gas tank today may feel worse off even when the average across Trump’s entire second term remains below Biden’s.
Wages and household wealth complicate the picture
Whether Americans are actually poorer depends on more than consumer prices. Michael Ryan, a personal finance expert interviewed by Newsweek, argued that inflation-adjusted incomes and wages were slightly higher by some measures, while household wealth had reached record levels.
The Federal Reserve reported that household and nonprofit net worth climbed to $195.9 trillion in the second quarter of 2026, supported largely by gains in stock values.
But those gains don’t reach everyone equally. The latest BLS real earnings report found inflation-adjusted average hourly earnings fell 0.7% between September 2025 and September 2026.
Voters remain divided over which economy was better
Americans aren’t united on the comparison, either. A July 2026 Harvard CAPS/Harris poll found that 50% of registered voters believed the economy was better under Trump than Biden, while the other half disagreed.
More recent polling suggests affordability concerns have intensified. An October Pew Research Center survey found 65% of Americans believed Trump’s economic policies had worsened conditions, while 19% said they had improved them.
For voters, personal experience may carry more weight than nationwide averages. A growing retirement account won’t necessarily offset the frustration of paying more for groceries, electricity, insurance, and gasoline every month.
Bottom line
Are Americans poorer under Trump than Biden, or are they simply struggling with higher prices accumulated across both presidencies? The evidence supports different conclusions depending on whether you examine inflation, real wages, household wealth, or gasoline costs. Paul’s warning highlights genuine purchasing-power concerns, but it doesn’t establish that every American is financially worse off.
For retirees and those approaching retirement, the practical response is to measure how your own income compares with rising essential expenses rather than relying on political claims alone. Reviewing your budget, adjusting discretionary spending, and identifying ways to supplement fixed income can help you lower your financial stress regardless of which administration is in office.
Subscribe Today
Learn how to make an extra $200
Get vetted side hustles and proven ways to earn extra cash sent to your inbox.
